“Zestimates” and why you should trust your real estate broker.
August 24, 2009 Incline Village Information, Lake Tahoe Information, Market Information No CommentsEveryone has an idea of what a home should be worth – the bank, the buyer, the seller, the agent, the appraiser, and now Zillow. Zillow creates what is known as a “zestimate”. Other websites have created automated valuation tools as well. They are marketed with other catchy names and the general concept is the same.
Spokespersons for Zillow.com explain that a zestimate is an automated valuation of your home, primarily derived from public records, local listings and sales information. Zillow.com stresses that the zestimate is a starting point when doing research – not a final appraisal.

There are zestimates for 88 million homes on Zillow.com, and new data is being added to the real estate Web site all the time. But when you go online and look up your home’s worth, is the zestimate reliable? Is this a figure you can trust?
If you are looking at a home in the suburbs where an entire tract has the same floor plan, the answer is probably yes. But if you are considering a home in Incline Village or Crystal Bay, it is probably not accurate.
Zillow.com says it has a 10 percent margin of error in its zestimates in Washoe County, and that’s not even considering the impact of Tahoe Basin regulations, the lake views, Incline Village amenities and the various neighborhoods of Incline Village and Crystal Bay.
Look up a home on Zillow.com and you can tell if the zestimate is close to accurate or not. Check on the value range – the wider the range the less confident Zillow is about its zestimate. Look at the value over time chart and compare a zestimate with the actual price of the last sale. If it doesn’t match, the trend is less reliable.
Finally, Zillow can’t put a value on the view (such as a view of Lake Tahoe), the value of recent improvements, the condition of a home, or that all important factor – location, location, location.
Zillow.com also has a short online video that discusses zestimates, how they are created, and how much weight you should give them when pricing your home or future purchase.
So start at Zillow.com, but don’t end there. Come by Lakeshore Realty and speak with a professional. Our brokers (who know Incline and Crystal Bay inside out) will fill in the missing pieces that a web site just can’t zestimate.

